Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Brundage's avatar

Awesome article Steve. Though I disagree with the “If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck (etc) then it’s a duck” approach to consciousness, I think it shows us something critical: real or fake, sometimes our brains can’t tell the difference.

I’m glad you brought up the issue of animal consciousness because I think that debate sheds some light here. For example, to justify eating meat, many question the degree to which animals truly suffer. William Lane Craig has an interesting argument that animals lack sufficient self consciousness to experience suffering in the same sense that humans do. Some even deny animal suffering altogether.

But what’s always struck me is that even if these arguments are correct, animal cruelty would still be a telltale sign of pathology, and a reliable way to identify potential serial killers. For me, something has gone seriously wrong if we become so desensitized to the manifestations of suffering that we’re capable of ignoring them just because our pet metaphysical theory can’t account for them. Just as I wouldn’t trust someone who could torture a dog without feeling anything, I wouldn’t trust someone who could be abusive toward LaMDA without feeling anything.

Where the analogy breaks off for me is that I think whatever animals experience is close enough to human suffering that we need to give them some moral status. I won’t lose any sleep wondering whether LaMDA is actually conscious. But I do think that when something resembles consciousness so closely that we can’t tell the difference I think it’s not a good idea to suspend our human instincts to kindness.

Expand full comment
Derek's avatar

Helluva post, Steve. I tip my hat. Erudite, balanced, chock full of references and supporting info. and provocative to boot. You made sense of very difficult terrain and translated jargon and concepts that allowed a tech neophyte (volitional) like me to navigate and grapple with the breadth of considerations and potential implications. I saw the lamda news when it first hit the wires and my radar went off. We seem as a species to be at a weird (ominous?) nexus in history, e.g., slo-mo disclosure with UAPs, sci-fi AI increasingly becoming pedestrian, etc. I was a bit surprised your Orthodox buddy - credentialed out the wazoo for sure, so it ratified his opinion for me to a degree - portend a future sentient AI. Btw, if you wanna see a holy sh*t conversation about AI and our future, check out Tucker Carlson’s long-form interview of James Barrat (Man vs. Machine).

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts