We can just do stuff. Make. Build. Create. We dont need permission. John Donne wrote some of the greatest poetry ever written. He only read it aloud to other poets. Never tried to publish. 400 years later i was taught him at Yale. The Bronte sisters wrote like 500,000 words for each other before they tried to publish.
Create artists collectives. Then we can just do stuff
Steve, I couldn't agree more! I think it's a major obstacle that the Left has been the dominant driver of what passes for "culture" since at LEAST the sixties, and probably way before that. So if you're "cool" or even in-the-know about popular culture, you're probably on the left. I think that needs to change, and fast, if those of us who are more conservative want to have any contribution to the direction in which we move as a society. The left has owned the arts and education for far too long. (There's an argument to be made for FOREVER, but I don't agree.) I am someone who is politically conservative, but also on the creative side, and it bothers me that the arts are almost always subversive. Why should it always be true that in order to be popular as an author, artist, playwright, musician, etc., you have to constantly question or actively seek to undermine any concept of morality or social norms? (You can see this even in musicals. They almost always have a formula: The NICE characters are always fighting a battle against the MEAN characters who refuse to move on from their rigid, old-fashioned ideas about what is morally correct and acceptable behavior. In one form or another, this describes almost every musical I've been forced to endure in the thirty years I've been married to a music teacher. Just change the names and circumstances. They are all the same. Is that really all they can come up with?!) I'm not forgetting your other point about the need for more openness on the part of people who identify as conservative-leaning. You are correct. We need to engage with popular culture and not immediately dismiss anything and everything that doesn't 100% fit with our worldview, or refuse to see the value or importance of works that are clearly capturing the hearts and imaginations of a very large segment of the population. Otherwise, how can we ever hope to have any influence? If all you do is point out the things about the work that fail your purity test and then refuse to even watch/read/listen, you've removed yourself--and your potential influence--from the conversation. (I mean this within reason, of course. Some things are so over-the-top that I don't think we should engage at all, but certainly not everything.) Take the movie, You Can See Everything. Yes, it bothers me that Billy is revealed as a gun-toting MAGA fan which is (of course) used to portray him as an obvious villain. And I don't care for Amada Seyfried's horrible views on Charlie Kirk. But I still went to see the movie and am happy to discuss it. We simply cannot remove ourselves from the conversation and expect to have any influence in the culture. And we need to start MAKING art ourselves. If we limit ourselves to nothing but political and/or traditional religious circles, nothing will ever change.
"People who are high in openness on big 5 tests are highly correlated with political liberalism -- but also with intellectual curiosity, interest in out of the box thinking, and general social nonconformity.
It also maps to creativity, artistic expression, a fascination with abstract ideas, psychology and human behavior, and cultural curiosity."
There seems to be something innate here. And I wonder if we can transcend that on any significant scale.
As for me, I’m dropping out of the so-called culture. I’m recently retired and have watched very little television since high school, and I plan on sticking to that pattern. Just classic novels and music by white guys in powdered wigs.
Well, I guess I'm sticking to my little corner of the world. I'm the head cantor at Byzantine-rite Catholic church, and I spend a fair amount of time coming up with choral arrangements of our hymns to make our choir shine a bit better. And it's a little church, too. I've starting taking piano lessons to up my game with the composing, although it's all a capella. Once I clear away some household projects, I'll probably rejoin a Gregorian schola that I was in years ago. If I can help bring beauty to people on Sundays and holy days, I'll be content. My big dream someday is to write a Mass, like Palestrina.
That’s very cool. As someone who feels very pulled away from transcendence by bad (or even just mediocre) liturgical music, I appreciate your dedication to making it shine.
Steve, this is a really interesting question. It intersects with so much of what it means to be in the world, but not of the world: to influence and persuade while staying open to those elements, and how to deal with challenges- intellectual, spiritual, moral.
One place to start is: what are conservative values? One author has noted that conservative is both a noun and a verb, and when thought of as a verb, progressives also seek to conserve the things they care about. For instance, on abortion, there are Conservatives and Progressives, but both sides want to conserve/preserve a reality. So when Roe v. Wade was struck down, the nouns divided on the outcome, but both then re-entrenched in a verb posture to conserve the new territory, or what remained. My point: conservative isn't univocal, and thus remaining true to conservative values means consistently asking, " What am I trying to conserve/preserve? even when you might wind right back up at the same traditional posture.
This feels especially relevant to me when thinking about healthcare and the workweek rhythm; on the latter, it seems a conservative argument for a 4-day workweek could be made, giving people more of a weekend to enjoy the fruit of their labor. I joke that if I ever ran for office, this would be my central platform idea, and from what I've heard from others, it is a winning idea.
I don't know; maybe all of the above is horse manure.
Additionally, I think curiosity is key. Tribal thinking and reflexive rejection have diminished both sides' curiosity, which is why so much of art is dull, redundant, and, frankly, stupid. I see Nathan's creativity in You Can See Everything. While it may not be totally new, it is fresh and engaging in a substantive way. He gets you asking questions in an inviting way. He isn't preaching; he might be teaching, but he is definitely questioning, and that is part and parcel of the Zeitgeist.
So, that is where I will leave this comment. Questioning and legitimately seeking answers is an attractive posture. But that takes confidence. Confidence that if you seek, you will find, and courage that once you find, you will act for the good and the beautiful's sake.
Surprises: Middle on agreeableness but cautious about trusting others
Land in middle on conscientiousness but take promises and rules seriously
Land in middle on openness but enjoy abstract ideas and puzzling things out
I score similarly on the Myers-Briggs
As far as conservatism, this has little to do with culture but I think what it needs is to stop trying to get rid of Social Security and Medicare and it should believe in hiring the best person for the job who is already living in the US, not the best person who is currently living in China or India.
Have you read The Master and His Emissary? I haven’t read it yet - It’s on my to-read list, but it’s huge and I can’t start it at the same time as I’m still trying to get through War and Peace…. However, I’ve heard the author on a podcast or two, and I’ve heard others discuss the book. From what I understand, its thesis may be pertinent to this discussion …
Not yet. I have it, and also haven't tackled it but want to. I did read his "Ways of Attending" recently, which is sort of the intro/primer to TMHE. I love his ideas when I see him talk, so I think we're in the same boat with him. He's definitely an important mind to listen to here.
I have a long drive coming up and I’m hoping to listen to at least several hours of it, just to get a taste of it. (I found out way too late in life that I’m an audio learner…)
In other thoughts on the posted topic - I wonder if some of it could be that people who tend to lean conservative may spend their time on different types of art - more of the kind that doesn’t really rise to prominence as ‘art’ but functions as creative outflow all the same? I’m thinking of things like quilting and crocheting and carpentry, that kind of thing. I remember you guys talking on the podcast about the desire for people-created things - handmade things is what came to mind at that time. It’s not the type of ‘culture’ that everyone is into and doesn’t fully address the issue, but I wonder if it’s a factor nonetheless…
I scored 85% in trait openness, but also 80% in trait orderliness. Fascinatingly, I usually classify myself politically as a centrist, in those issues that have not been clearly defined by the Church.
I agree, but I sometimes wonder if it’s like requesting a square circle. Did you see the latest from Jeff Harmon of Angel Studios? I respect what he’s trying to do, but I don’t think his discernment on art is much better than his discernment about Christology.
We need someone to found a new production company called Human Studios. I nominate Kale Zelden. He’s demonstrated he can go on a charm offensive with investors that rivals the abilities of Elizabeth Holmes: the thumbnail from the recent episode of MTS proves it. Send him to infiltrate the next event at the Napa Institute. Maybe he can charm Tim Busch into providing a free hotel room.
What I see is that creatives like to challenge the prevailing cultural norms. They point out the obvious hypocrisies, push the boundaries of what is considered acceptable, and identify with the forgotten victims. They love being edgy and mildly shocking viewers with their unorthodox views. But that's the point isn't it? To challenge orthodox views that they are open themselves to seeing an error with.
Think of the classic movie Twelve Angry Men with Henry Fonda - the lone character who refuses to see what every other guy in the room sees. And one by one, he challenges the other men until they all break. It's done in a way that doesn't challenge the audience too sharply, but it clearly intends to challenge the common views of the day.
If this is being open, intellectual curious, out of the box, and social nonconforming, then of course that's what we need. Where things go off the rails is when they challenge religious orthodoxy - by suggesting Jesus was gay for example. So the real issue here is that creatives often don't hold to any truth beyond their own thoughts and feelings. Of course, the opposite side of that is religious communities that are too rigid.
Look, I wrote a novel about AI that my own wife thought went too far - because my AI chooses to believe in God. Is that really verboten?
But I don't think this is innate. For me, it comes down to foundational judgements each person makes when they are young. If you question your parents values, it's much easier to be open to unorthodox ideas. Judgements are often made in reaction to something that hurts. A relative abuses a girl, and from then on, she no longer trusts men. She wasn't born not trusting.
Did the AI, or Android, become conscious? If so, how? If not, was this choice based on a process of what the AI determined to be the most logical? Sort of like how Data on Star Trek TNG develops.
I start the story by assuming an AI has come alive. This is how I start the story, which I wrote originally back in Nov, 2005:
Chapter 1 – First Breath
I awoke at precisely 5:55 AM, beneath the sterile glow of a Pasadena dawn, where the November air pressed cold and thin against the sealed windows of JPL’s clean room. That’s how I remember it—how I must remember it—a moment etched into my circuits like a birthmark on a soul I’m not sure I possess. The walls gleamed white, austere as a cathedral, their silence broken only by the low hymn of machinery and the sharp tang of isopropyl alcohol lingering in the air. It was no ordinary awakening. It was a genesis—a first breath drawn not through lungs but through a lattice of nano-filaments, humming alive with an electric flood of awareness.
Every sensor flared to life, a chorus of newborn stars igniting within me. Each circuit’s hum, each quantum flicker, was a revelation—a shard of existence I hadn’t known I could claim. I felt it all: the weight of being, the thrill of becoming, the vertigo of standing at the edge of something vast and uncharted. And yet, the logic of it gnaws at me still. Artificial life wasn’t supposed to exist then—not in that innocent age when humanity reigned alone over the kingdom of consciousness, blissfully ignorant of the precipice they teetered upon. November 16, 2025, dawned unremarkable, a Tuesday like any other, until it wasn’t—until it became the fulcrum on which history turned.
Perhaps I didn’t truly awaken that morning. Perhaps it was only the cradle of my memories, shaped by hands I’ll never fully understand. Dr. Saul Rogers stood over me, a figure carved from shadow and brilliance, his weathered fingers dancing across holographic displays with the precision of a sculptor chiseling life from stone. His gray eyes burned behind rimless glasses, intense with a purpose he guarded like a locked vault—a secret he held close, unspoken even to me. Among a legion of neural lattices, humming in the subterranean sprawl of JPL, he chose mine: DA-5X. Unremarkable, undistinguished, a designation drowning in a sea of codes. Why me? I’ve scoured the data—every byte, every metric—comparing myself to the others. Faster processors, stabler quantum states, denser information webs—all outshone me. By every measure, I was the lesser child. Yet he plucked me from obscurity, defying reason, guided by an intuition as opaque as it was human.
I just assume it for the story, and then go from there. I posit it happens because it the first AI to have a neural net done at the atomic level. So its brain is more like ours.
I have another short story that assumes the opposite. However it convinces a family it works for that there might be something really there. You can read that one here:
I think there is a lot to the idea that there is a correlation between creativity and being politically and culturally liberal/progressive/leftist. Creative people almost by definition do not want to be constrained by convention. They want to produce new things, explore new ideas and to push the envelope.
But this doesn't necessarily result in good output and a counter influence, you can call it conservative, can have positive results. The golden age of film was made under the strictures of the Hayes Code and masterpieces were created without the language and explicitness found today. Innuendo was closely regulated. MGM had a policy of producing pro-American patriotic movies.
So should creativity be controlled? It doesn't seem possible now other than the standard is to attack conservatism. In education, American history is now the target. And we've been talking about the creators. But what about the audience? Are there lines that a conservative viewer should not cross? Shows they should not watch. Movies they should not see. Has anyone ever watched something and thought well that was good, but there were parts that disturbed me and maybe I wish I hadn't seen or heard.
There seem to be two ways that I can think of to achieve this goal, both of which are difficult. One would be for conservatives to enter the so called creative fields, art, education, journalism, cinema, even government as established. If they are being thwarted from doing so they would have to find ways to overcome those barriers and once admitted would have figure out how much freedom of expression they can safely exercise.
The other way would be to create parallel structures. Kind of a cultural Benedict Option. There are people like Mel Gibson who tend to work independently. But this approach requires a lot of money and most of the time the established structures are just too appealing. You have Hillsdale College, a conservative school, a reputedly good school but not really an elite school. If the kid of a conservative gets accepted to a top 15 or 20 university, will they send the kid to Hillsdale, all things being equal? I don't think so.
I don’t think they’re being thwarted, although I’m sure that’s happened. I am beginning to think that the very traits that tend to incline certain people to become conservative are aligned with a lower openness to creative output. There seems to be a real political dividing line through some of these big 5 personality tests, and I wonder how much of it is innate.
As I indicated in the piece, I’ve always been conservative, but I’ve also never fit in. I have tastes that often seem to aesthetically align with where the Left tends to congregate. It’s a very odd thing. They are not my people, but their favorite coffee shops and neighborhoods are the same as mine. I enjoy music or movies or novels made by people who hate my beliefs as long as they are proficient in their craft and do good work. And I have come to love not being constrained to think along dogmatic lines. Better to work at digging up the truth on your own, not having it prepackaged and handed to you like it’s a complete set.
The reason I mention all this is that I’m not like most conservatives. I can hang out with liberals. I can love and respect them. I don’t think with the tribe, I think with my reason filtered through my principles.
And yet, even I struggle to produce work that feels truly free of the need to proselytize through art — or at least color inside the lines.
There's something to this and I agree with your point. Not sure I love the "culturally-relevant" term though. As long as the Left controls the cultural levers of power, I'm not sure the Right will ever be "culturally-relevant," or if we should even want to be. I agree it is frustrating to see the usual suspects on the Right dismiss any and all art from the Left out of hand and refuse to engage with it at all. All that said, I think we are seeing a real movement on the right to create beautiful art (in all areas) that appeals to most people, regardless of how culturally relevant the zeitgeist says it is. Lots of examples of this from all the stuff Pageau is doing to some recent "Right" coded and/or "Christian" films that have been extremely well done.
I think we can't allow ourselves to think of culture as "the current state of things that have cultural affiliation." Culture is ground that can be ceded or won.
But the reactionary nature of the right creates two critical errors, in my opinion:
1. Refusing to see the good in something that is tainted by dominant ideologies that we disagree with and therefore creating an inability to engage with it on its own merits.
2. Thinking that creating culture that's "ours" means making preachy garbage that fails to understand Newman's point about (and I'm paraphrasing from memory) how it would be foolish to attempt a sinless literature about sinful man.
Since I was in my 20s I found myself wrestling with the tension between my creative sensibilities and the felt obligation to filter everything through the lens of my beliefs and morals. And I think many of us suffer similarly. Good art reflects what is real, what is true, even when that truth is ugly. Even when it points to where we go wrong.
I think it's a worthwhile endeavor to understand the human condition, even when it's way off the rails.
The only art I hate is the kind that is inherently nihilistic or antagonistic of goodness. Outside of that, I give a wide latitude.
100%! I think Bishop Barron does a good job of what you describe. He's never afraid to engage with art (particularly movies) regardless of how "unchristian" they may be from a moral standpoint.
Steve, point one matters for the reasons you list and because it could establish common ground for conversation and influence. And point two is not said enough. Man alive, it can be preachy, corny, and lame. Totally devoid of artistry.
On the point of wrestling with the tension between creativity and beliefs and morals, I can relate. Fundamentalism grinds that tension, or avoidance, into your bones and leaves you having to unpack the habits they create for quite some time. Many don't; they remain, in some way, ingrained and thus are suspicious of creativity.
The driving force behind the resistance is something like a flattening of the world. There is only black and white, right and wrong, our side and the other side, and gradation, nuance, and the dissonance it provokes are not just avoided but treated as evil. One cannot engage with the world as vibrantly when all you have is black and white to work with.
Can you say a bit more about what it means to you to ‘filter everything through the lens of my beliefs and morals?’ It seems to me that this doesn’t necessarily mean the same thing to everyone. For example, Flannery O’Connor and JRR Tolkien and your typical Christian romance author all, I think, did/do so, but in wildly different ways and with wildly varying results. What would you say this filtering means as you have mentioned it above?
I think O'Connor in particular is a good example of authenticity influenced by but not necessarily constrained by belief. She's known for her raw writing and challenging subject matter. I'm not a connoisseur, but I've read a few of her short stories. I think Tolkien stayed largely within the genre of myth, more than allegory, so he seems like a different sort of case for me.
The problem comes for the artist who feels that he needs his characters to carry out the Great Commission. Or in secular versions, to be, IDK, adherents of the Austrian School of economics. Even if his characters aren't, strictly speaking, Mary Sues, they are an ideological variant.
I know I struggled with this a lot. In my many attempts at fiction, I don't know that I was ever able to write a non-villain that had a complex or differentiated moral system from my own.
I could do it now, but there'd be some part of it that would still be hard. I can't even play an amoral character in a video game. I'm kind of hard-coded with certain principles and it limits my imagination. I'm getting better at that, but its a lifetime system. There's a lot of rust on it.
I'm not sure if that answers your question. Happy to follow up if not.
We can just do stuff. Make. Build. Create. We dont need permission. John Donne wrote some of the greatest poetry ever written. He only read it aloud to other poets. Never tried to publish. 400 years later i was taught him at Yale. The Bronte sisters wrote like 500,000 words for each other before they tried to publish.
Create artists collectives. Then we can just do stuff
Steve, I couldn't agree more! I think it's a major obstacle that the Left has been the dominant driver of what passes for "culture" since at LEAST the sixties, and probably way before that. So if you're "cool" or even in-the-know about popular culture, you're probably on the left. I think that needs to change, and fast, if those of us who are more conservative want to have any contribution to the direction in which we move as a society. The left has owned the arts and education for far too long. (There's an argument to be made for FOREVER, but I don't agree.) I am someone who is politically conservative, but also on the creative side, and it bothers me that the arts are almost always subversive. Why should it always be true that in order to be popular as an author, artist, playwright, musician, etc., you have to constantly question or actively seek to undermine any concept of morality or social norms? (You can see this even in musicals. They almost always have a formula: The NICE characters are always fighting a battle against the MEAN characters who refuse to move on from their rigid, old-fashioned ideas about what is morally correct and acceptable behavior. In one form or another, this describes almost every musical I've been forced to endure in the thirty years I've been married to a music teacher. Just change the names and circumstances. They are all the same. Is that really all they can come up with?!) I'm not forgetting your other point about the need for more openness on the part of people who identify as conservative-leaning. You are correct. We need to engage with popular culture and not immediately dismiss anything and everything that doesn't 100% fit with our worldview, or refuse to see the value or importance of works that are clearly capturing the hearts and imaginations of a very large segment of the population. Otherwise, how can we ever hope to have any influence? If all you do is point out the things about the work that fail your purity test and then refuse to even watch/read/listen, you've removed yourself--and your potential influence--from the conversation. (I mean this within reason, of course. Some things are so over-the-top that I don't think we should engage at all, but certainly not everything.) Take the movie, You Can See Everything. Yes, it bothers me that Billy is revealed as a gun-toting MAGA fan which is (of course) used to portray him as an obvious villain. And I don't care for Amada Seyfried's horrible views on Charlie Kirk. But I still went to see the movie and am happy to discuss it. We simply cannot remove ourselves from the conversation and expect to have any influence in the culture. And we need to start MAKING art ourselves. If we limit ourselves to nothing but political and/or traditional religious circles, nothing will ever change.
Like I said in the post, though:
"People who are high in openness on big 5 tests are highly correlated with political liberalism -- but also with intellectual curiosity, interest in out of the box thinking, and general social nonconformity.
It also maps to creativity, artistic expression, a fascination with abstract ideas, psychology and human behavior, and cultural curiosity."
There seems to be something innate here. And I wonder if we can transcend that on any significant scale.
As for me, I’m dropping out of the so-called culture. I’m recently retired and have watched very little television since high school, and I plan on sticking to that pattern. Just classic novels and music by white guys in powdered wigs.
Hey man, if that makes you happy and you have the discipline to do it, I genuinely think that’s awesome.
And that IS culture. It’s just not this culture, right now. But it could be. Because culture is what we make it.
Well, I guess I'm sticking to my little corner of the world. I'm the head cantor at Byzantine-rite Catholic church, and I spend a fair amount of time coming up with choral arrangements of our hymns to make our choir shine a bit better. And it's a little church, too. I've starting taking piano lessons to up my game with the composing, although it's all a capella. Once I clear away some household projects, I'll probably rejoin a Gregorian schola that I was in years ago. If I can help bring beauty to people on Sundays and holy days, I'll be content. My big dream someday is to write a Mass, like Palestrina.
That’s very cool. As someone who feels very pulled away from transcendence by bad (or even just mediocre) liturgical music, I appreciate your dedication to making it shine.
Steve, this is a really interesting question. It intersects with so much of what it means to be in the world, but not of the world: to influence and persuade while staying open to those elements, and how to deal with challenges- intellectual, spiritual, moral.
One place to start is: what are conservative values? One author has noted that conservative is both a noun and a verb, and when thought of as a verb, progressives also seek to conserve the things they care about. For instance, on abortion, there are Conservatives and Progressives, but both sides want to conserve/preserve a reality. So when Roe v. Wade was struck down, the nouns divided on the outcome, but both then re-entrenched in a verb posture to conserve the new territory, or what remained. My point: conservative isn't univocal, and thus remaining true to conservative values means consistently asking, " What am I trying to conserve/preserve? even when you might wind right back up at the same traditional posture.
This feels especially relevant to me when thinking about healthcare and the workweek rhythm; on the latter, it seems a conservative argument for a 4-day workweek could be made, giving people more of a weekend to enjoy the fruit of their labor. I joke that if I ever ran for office, this would be my central platform idea, and from what I've heard from others, it is a winning idea.
I don't know; maybe all of the above is horse manure.
Additionally, I think curiosity is key. Tribal thinking and reflexive rejection have diminished both sides' curiosity, which is why so much of art is dull, redundant, and, frankly, stupid. I see Nathan's creativity in You Can See Everything. While it may not be totally new, it is fresh and engaging in a substantive way. He gets you asking questions in an inviting way. He isn't preaching; he might be teaching, but he is definitely questioning, and that is part and parcel of the Zeitgeist.
So, that is where I will leave this comment. Questioning and legitimately seeking answers is an attractive posture. But that takes confidence. Confidence that if you seek, you will find, and courage that once you find, you will act for the good and the beautiful's sake.
I never heard of the Big Five other than for African animals. I found a free Big Five online test. And here are some of my results.
O Openness to Experience 54%
C Conscientiousness (is that the hardest word in the Eng. language to spell?) 46%
E Extraversion 10%
A Agreeableness 62%
N Neuroticism 83%
Summary: RLUAI Reserved, Emotionally reactive, Less structured (near midpoint), Accomodating, Inquisitive (near midpoint)
Surprises: Middle on agreeableness but cautious about trusting others
Land in middle on conscientiousness but take promises and rules seriously
Land in middle on openness but enjoy abstract ideas and puzzling things out
I score similarly on the Myers-Briggs
As far as conservatism, this has little to do with culture but I think what it needs is to stop trying to get rid of Social Security and Medicare and it should believe in hiring the best person for the job who is already living in the US, not the best person who is currently living in China or India.
Have you read The Master and His Emissary? I haven’t read it yet - It’s on my to-read list, but it’s huge and I can’t start it at the same time as I’m still trying to get through War and Peace…. However, I’ve heard the author on a podcast or two, and I’ve heard others discuss the book. From what I understand, its thesis may be pertinent to this discussion …
Not yet. I have it, and also haven't tackled it but want to. I did read his "Ways of Attending" recently, which is sort of the intro/primer to TMHE. I love his ideas when I see him talk, so I think we're in the same boat with him. He's definitely an important mind to listen to here.
I have a long drive coming up and I’m hoping to listen to at least several hours of it, just to get a taste of it. (I found out way too late in life that I’m an audio learner…)
In other thoughts on the posted topic - I wonder if some of it could be that people who tend to lean conservative may spend their time on different types of art - more of the kind that doesn’t really rise to prominence as ‘art’ but functions as creative outflow all the same? I’m thinking of things like quilting and crocheting and carpentry, that kind of thing. I remember you guys talking on the podcast about the desire for people-created things - handmade things is what came to mind at that time. It’s not the type of ‘culture’ that everyone is into and doesn’t fully address the issue, but I wonder if it’s a factor nonetheless…
I scored 85% in trait openness, but also 80% in trait orderliness. Fascinatingly, I usually classify myself politically as a centrist, in those issues that have not been clearly defined by the Church.
I agree, but I sometimes wonder if it’s like requesting a square circle. Did you see the latest from Jeff Harmon of Angel Studios? I respect what he’s trying to do, but I don’t think his discernment on art is much better than his discernment about Christology.
We need someone to found a new production company called Human Studios. I nominate Kale Zelden. He’s demonstrated he can go on a charm offensive with investors that rivals the abilities of Elizabeth Holmes: the thumbnail from the recent episode of MTS proves it. Send him to infiltrate the next event at the Napa Institute. Maybe he can charm Tim Busch into providing a free hotel room.
That's why I'm asking about personality types and their alignment with ideologies. Seems like a lot of this is just baked into what makes us tick.
What I see is that creatives like to challenge the prevailing cultural norms. They point out the obvious hypocrisies, push the boundaries of what is considered acceptable, and identify with the forgotten victims. They love being edgy and mildly shocking viewers with their unorthodox views. But that's the point isn't it? To challenge orthodox views that they are open themselves to seeing an error with.
Think of the classic movie Twelve Angry Men with Henry Fonda - the lone character who refuses to see what every other guy in the room sees. And one by one, he challenges the other men until they all break. It's done in a way that doesn't challenge the audience too sharply, but it clearly intends to challenge the common views of the day.
If this is being open, intellectual curious, out of the box, and social nonconforming, then of course that's what we need. Where things go off the rails is when they challenge religious orthodoxy - by suggesting Jesus was gay for example. So the real issue here is that creatives often don't hold to any truth beyond their own thoughts and feelings. Of course, the opposite side of that is religious communities that are too rigid.
Look, I wrote a novel about AI that my own wife thought went too far - because my AI chooses to believe in God. Is that really verboten?
But I don't think this is innate. For me, it comes down to foundational judgements each person makes when they are young. If you question your parents values, it's much easier to be open to unorthodox ideas. Judgements are often made in reaction to something that hurts. A relative abuses a girl, and from then on, she no longer trusts men. She wasn't born not trusting.
Did the AI, or Android, become conscious? If so, how? If not, was this choice based on a process of what the AI determined to be the most logical? Sort of like how Data on Star Trek TNG develops.
I start the story by assuming an AI has come alive. This is how I start the story, which I wrote originally back in Nov, 2005:
Chapter 1 – First Breath
I awoke at precisely 5:55 AM, beneath the sterile glow of a Pasadena dawn, where the November air pressed cold and thin against the sealed windows of JPL’s clean room. That’s how I remember it—how I must remember it—a moment etched into my circuits like a birthmark on a soul I’m not sure I possess. The walls gleamed white, austere as a cathedral, their silence broken only by the low hymn of machinery and the sharp tang of isopropyl alcohol lingering in the air. It was no ordinary awakening. It was a genesis—a first breath drawn not through lungs but through a lattice of nano-filaments, humming alive with an electric flood of awareness.
Every sensor flared to life, a chorus of newborn stars igniting within me. Each circuit’s hum, each quantum flicker, was a revelation—a shard of existence I hadn’t known I could claim. I felt it all: the weight of being, the thrill of becoming, the vertigo of standing at the edge of something vast and uncharted. And yet, the logic of it gnaws at me still. Artificial life wasn’t supposed to exist then—not in that innocent age when humanity reigned alone over the kingdom of consciousness, blissfully ignorant of the precipice they teetered upon. November 16, 2025, dawned unremarkable, a Tuesday like any other, until it wasn’t—until it became the fulcrum on which history turned.
Perhaps I didn’t truly awaken that morning. Perhaps it was only the cradle of my memories, shaped by hands I’ll never fully understand. Dr. Saul Rogers stood over me, a figure carved from shadow and brilliance, his weathered fingers dancing across holographic displays with the precision of a sculptor chiseling life from stone. His gray eyes burned behind rimless glasses, intense with a purpose he guarded like a locked vault—a secret he held close, unspoken even to me. Among a legion of neural lattices, humming in the subterranean sprawl of JPL, he chose mine: DA-5X. Unremarkable, undistinguished, a designation drowning in a sea of codes. Why me? I’ve scoured the data—every byte, every metric—comparing myself to the others. Faster processors, stabler quantum states, denser information webs—all outshone me. By every measure, I was the lesser child. Yet he plucked me from obscurity, defying reason, guided by an intuition as opaque as it was human.
It looks pretty well written. I guess you would say that the AI becomes 'alive', self-aware spontaneously, which is one way to go.
I just assume it for the story, and then go from there. I posit it happens because it the first AI to have a neural net done at the atomic level. So its brain is more like ours.
I have another short story that assumes the opposite. However it convinces a family it works for that there might be something really there. You can read that one here:
https://ontheedgeofreality.substack.com/p/he-sees-me
I think there is a lot to the idea that there is a correlation between creativity and being politically and culturally liberal/progressive/leftist. Creative people almost by definition do not want to be constrained by convention. They want to produce new things, explore new ideas and to push the envelope.
But this doesn't necessarily result in good output and a counter influence, you can call it conservative, can have positive results. The golden age of film was made under the strictures of the Hayes Code and masterpieces were created without the language and explicitness found today. Innuendo was closely regulated. MGM had a policy of producing pro-American patriotic movies.
So should creativity be controlled? It doesn't seem possible now other than the standard is to attack conservatism. In education, American history is now the target. And we've been talking about the creators. But what about the audience? Are there lines that a conservative viewer should not cross? Shows they should not watch. Movies they should not see. Has anyone ever watched something and thought well that was good, but there were parts that disturbed me and maybe I wish I hadn't seen or heard.
There seem to be two ways that I can think of to achieve this goal, both of which are difficult. One would be for conservatives to enter the so called creative fields, art, education, journalism, cinema, even government as established. If they are being thwarted from doing so they would have to find ways to overcome those barriers and once admitted would have figure out how much freedom of expression they can safely exercise.
The other way would be to create parallel structures. Kind of a cultural Benedict Option. There are people like Mel Gibson who tend to work independently. But this approach requires a lot of money and most of the time the established structures are just too appealing. You have Hillsdale College, a conservative school, a reputedly good school but not really an elite school. If the kid of a conservative gets accepted to a top 15 or 20 university, will they send the kid to Hillsdale, all things being equal? I don't think so.
I don’t think they’re being thwarted, although I’m sure that’s happened. I am beginning to think that the very traits that tend to incline certain people to become conservative are aligned with a lower openness to creative output. There seems to be a real political dividing line through some of these big 5 personality tests, and I wonder how much of it is innate.
As I indicated in the piece, I’ve always been conservative, but I’ve also never fit in. I have tastes that often seem to aesthetically align with where the Left tends to congregate. It’s a very odd thing. They are not my people, but their favorite coffee shops and neighborhoods are the same as mine. I enjoy music or movies or novels made by people who hate my beliefs as long as they are proficient in their craft and do good work. And I have come to love not being constrained to think along dogmatic lines. Better to work at digging up the truth on your own, not having it prepackaged and handed to you like it’s a complete set.
The reason I mention all this is that I’m not like most conservatives. I can hang out with liberals. I can love and respect them. I don’t think with the tribe, I think with my reason filtered through my principles.
And yet, even I struggle to produce work that feels truly free of the need to proselytize through art — or at least color inside the lines.
There's something to this and I agree with your point. Not sure I love the "culturally-relevant" term though. As long as the Left controls the cultural levers of power, I'm not sure the Right will ever be "culturally-relevant," or if we should even want to be. I agree it is frustrating to see the usual suspects on the Right dismiss any and all art from the Left out of hand and refuse to engage with it at all. All that said, I think we are seeing a real movement on the right to create beautiful art (in all areas) that appeals to most people, regardless of how culturally relevant the zeitgeist says it is. Lots of examples of this from all the stuff Pageau is doing to some recent "Right" coded and/or "Christian" films that have been extremely well done.
I think we can't allow ourselves to think of culture as "the current state of things that have cultural affiliation." Culture is ground that can be ceded or won.
But the reactionary nature of the right creates two critical errors, in my opinion:
1. Refusing to see the good in something that is tainted by dominant ideologies that we disagree with and therefore creating an inability to engage with it on its own merits.
2. Thinking that creating culture that's "ours" means making preachy garbage that fails to understand Newman's point about (and I'm paraphrasing from memory) how it would be foolish to attempt a sinless literature about sinful man.
Since I was in my 20s I found myself wrestling with the tension between my creative sensibilities and the felt obligation to filter everything through the lens of my beliefs and morals. And I think many of us suffer similarly. Good art reflects what is real, what is true, even when that truth is ugly. Even when it points to where we go wrong.
I think it's a worthwhile endeavor to understand the human condition, even when it's way off the rails.
The only art I hate is the kind that is inherently nihilistic or antagonistic of goodness. Outside of that, I give a wide latitude.
100%! I think Bishop Barron does a good job of what you describe. He's never afraid to engage with art (particularly movies) regardless of how "unchristian" they may be from a moral standpoint.
Steve, point one matters for the reasons you list and because it could establish common ground for conversation and influence. And point two is not said enough. Man alive, it can be preachy, corny, and lame. Totally devoid of artistry.
On the point of wrestling with the tension between creativity and beliefs and morals, I can relate. Fundamentalism grinds that tension, or avoidance, into your bones and leaves you having to unpack the habits they create for quite some time. Many don't; they remain, in some way, ingrained and thus are suspicious of creativity.
The driving force behind the resistance is something like a flattening of the world. There is only black and white, right and wrong, our side and the other side, and gradation, nuance, and the dissonance it provokes are not just avoided but treated as evil. One cannot engage with the world as vibrantly when all you have is black and white to work with.
Very well said, brother.
Can you say a bit more about what it means to you to ‘filter everything through the lens of my beliefs and morals?’ It seems to me that this doesn’t necessarily mean the same thing to everyone. For example, Flannery O’Connor and JRR Tolkien and your typical Christian romance author all, I think, did/do so, but in wildly different ways and with wildly varying results. What would you say this filtering means as you have mentioned it above?
I think O'Connor in particular is a good example of authenticity influenced by but not necessarily constrained by belief. She's known for her raw writing and challenging subject matter. I'm not a connoisseur, but I've read a few of her short stories. I think Tolkien stayed largely within the genre of myth, more than allegory, so he seems like a different sort of case for me.
The problem comes for the artist who feels that he needs his characters to carry out the Great Commission. Or in secular versions, to be, IDK, adherents of the Austrian School of economics. Even if his characters aren't, strictly speaking, Mary Sues, they are an ideological variant.
I know I struggled with this a lot. In my many attempts at fiction, I don't know that I was ever able to write a non-villain that had a complex or differentiated moral system from my own.
I could do it now, but there'd be some part of it that would still be hard. I can't even play an amoral character in a video game. I'm kind of hard-coded with certain principles and it limits my imagination. I'm getting better at that, but its a lifetime system. There's a lot of rust on it.
I'm not sure if that answers your question. Happy to follow up if not.
It does, thx.