14 Comments
User's avatar
Patrick Nugent's avatar

Steve,

The story on the excommunication of the deacon in the Diocese of Lafayette really hurts. The bishop was my parish priest years ago. Maybe we don't know all the details, but this seems very unjust. Could the Bishop's response have been different? Something along the lines of "I am praying for you in this difficult time you are experiencing. I respect you decision to step away from the ministry of the deaconate, and will consider your ministry suspended for now. However, you are a child of God and a disciple of Christ. You are a member of the Body of Christ. I cannot give you any answers at this time to heal your wounds, but I will continue to pray for you. Your wounds are very real. I desire to help you find healing. My door is always open. Please feel free to visit with me at any time. Your brother in Christ."

Steve Skojec's avatar

That seems reasonable.

keithbostic's avatar

Correct me if I'm wrong (please!), but my understanding is no members of the Nazi regime in Germany were excommunicated. For better or worse, you don't get excommunicated for sin, no matter how awful, but read the wrong books and you're in trouble.

Thomas F Davis's avatar

No, there was a mass excommunication circa 1932 or 1933. It was de facto rescinded after the civil service was required to join the party.

keithbostic's avatar

Thank you!

I did not know that.

keithbostic's avatar

>> So, if we at least grant the possibility that this story is true — and Grusch has proven himself by every measure to be a credible guy with standup bona fides

Every measure? I think you're being more than a little kind to the man. At the least you're ignoring the mental illness (he's been committed twice, according to Wikipedia).

Grusch has, as far as I know, produced not a single piece of actual evidence to support his story. And let's remember this guy claimed alien spaceships might come from "other dimensions", which definitely moves him out of the "credible" category for me. I mean, what the hell does that even mean?

9 months ago, in a previous article on Grusch, I said "By next year, there will be no results whatsoever from this kerfuffle, except for the usual grifters looking for a few dollars, or maybe a book and/or a movie deal, based on their claims that the nefarious "they" are concealing the overwhelming evidence of space aliens."

It's tempting to congratulate myself pretty hard, except, well, it's like predicting that water will wet.

Steve Skojec's avatar

He suffered from combat and fatality related PTSD and related alcohol abuse. He had a friend die in the line of duty, and another kill himself shortly after they had a phone conversation. He sought treatment and was fully cleared and kept his clearances.

Trauma responses are not insanity, even if they are classed as a kind of mental illness.

And he provided evidence and witnesses to the inspector general of the intelligence community, who testified in closed session with cleared members of Congress. The ICIG also deemed Grusch’s claims “credible and urgent” based on his own classified testimony and that of witnesses.

The fact that classified evidence has not been made public is not surprising.

The Pentagon has been actively obfuscating. Both Sean Kirkpatrick and Susan Gough have been caught either outright lying or using evasive semantics to deceive.

When an institution is accused of corruption and malfeasance, you don’t ask that institution (especially when it has the power to classify and intimidate) to investigate itself.

Multiple members of Congress on both sides of the aisle have said that’s what’s happening here. Some have claimed to have seen evidence themselves.

The push to form a new UAP investigative committee in Congress just dropped in the last week.

The evidence will only come after a fight to get it from those who are accused of illegally concealing it, which should be obvious.

So maybe chill out and don’t throw yourself a party just yet.

keithbostic's avatar

PTSD is connected to maladaptive daydreaming -- I know nothing about the details of his issues, but if, as you say, he suffers from PTSD, then there's an obvious potential connection.

Steve Skojec's avatar

Again, he was psychologically cleared to maintain his top level clearances. He used to work on and deliver the Presidential Daily Briefing to the White House, so he was cleared at the highest level.

keithbostic's avatar

I hear you; but rational people do not talk about spaceships from "extra dimensions" and then bring up the holographic principle. Rational people don't claim Benito Mussolini's government recovered an alien spacecraft and the Vatican scored it for the US government.

Further, this is entirely an "appeal to authority", there isn't a shred of physical evidence to support Grusch. The pope speaks with a great deal of authority and certainty when he talks about Satan (and I'm sure his listeners would describe him as “credible and urgent”), but that doesn't mean Satan actually exists.