Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Daniel Koenemann's avatar

I sympathize with this. The older I get, the more I am thankful for the situation I grew up in. Perhaps one of the things I will always be grateful for is being able to remember the world without the internet. We didn’t even have a computer in my house until I was almost in high school and I never had access to anything but a dialup modem until I went to college. We did have technology education even as early as elementary school. Oh, how I hated it! I would never have then imagined that I would, as an adult, spend a good amount of time writing computer code for statistical analyses.

I have come to the conclusion that the world prior to the internet was by no means perfect, but it was better than what we have now. I was telling my mom just a few weeks ago that it seems to me that the overall impact of the internet on human society had been a negative one. There are for sure positive uses for the internet. The ability for hospitals to share information and help heal people, or the ability to more efficiently track and distribute goods. But so much of the internet seems to be a waste, or worse. Most social media seems to be just a globalized version of the smoke-filled-room experiment.

It’s hard to tell how much of this is nostalgia. When I talk to my grandfather, he has told me that the worst thing that ever happened to Vermont was the building of the interstate in the 1960s. Before that, it was very difficult to come to Vermont, and so very few people came, and it was better that way. He is probably right. It reminds me of Civilization and Its Discontents. Freud talks about how we so often marvel at technology being able to solve our problems. But, in fact, many if not most of the problems solved by technology are problems that technology itself created. Yes, the train gets me to the city faster, but I wouldn’t need to go to the city at all if the factory were never built. Or, more current, the scheduling app on my phone helps me manage my time, but I wouldn’t be so busy had I never gotten the phone. Freud isn’t completely right here, of course. The factory isn’t just some frivolous institution. The factory makes decent quality clothing available to almost everybody, or charcoal to easily heat my house, or canned food to more easily feed my children, or penicillin to easily cure infections. All things that humans in most of history would have fought wars for. The question is, how can we take the objective goods of technological advancement, without also accepting its pitfalls. And often, it seems like we only recognize the pit once we are already in it.

As for the living situation, you want the comforts of the Shire but the majesty of Gondor. In this life, I don’t think you can have both. My opinion. But, if you are looking for small towns with climbing trees and oceans, you are looking for New England. New Hampshire and Maine are both very nice places to live. So is Vermont, I might add, but we have no oceans.

Expand full comment
Fr. Joseph Krupp's avatar

This is beautiful. I just love your heart.

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts